Steam Cleaner vs Carpet Cleaner: Ultimate Guide for the Best Choice

When it comes to maintaining the cleanliness and hygiene of our carpets, steam cleaners and carpet cleaners are popular options. Both of these cleaning tools have their advantages and disadvantages, making it essential to understand their specific applications and capabilities.

Steam cleaners utilize high-temperature steam to remove dirt and kill bacteria, ensuring the carpet remains sanitized. On the other hand, carpet cleaners use cleaning solution and water to extract stains, dirt, and grime embedded in the carpet fibers, resulting in a refreshed and clean appearance.

Ultimately, the choice between a steam cleaner and a carpet cleaner depends on one’s specific needs and cleaning requirements.

Steam Cleaner Vs Carpet Cleaner: Basics

What Is a Steam Cleaner

A steam cleaner, as the name suggests, utilizes hot steam to clean various surfaces such as carpets, upholstery, and even hard floors. The cleaner heats water to a high temperature, converting it into steam. This steam is then released onto the surface through a cleaning attachment. The high-temperature steam not only removes dirt and stains but also disinfects, making steam cleaners ideal for deep cleaning and sanitizing tasks.

There are different types of steam cleaners, including handheld, mop-style, cylinder, and vapor steam cleaners, each catering to specific cleaning needs. High-quality steam cleaners can reach temperatures of around 200°F or higher, ensuring optimal cleaning performance.

What Is a Carpet Cleaner

Carpet cleaners, also known as carpet shampooers or carpet extractors, are specifically designed for cleaning carpets and rugs. They use a combination of water, cleaning solution, and powerful brushes to lift dirt, stains, and debris from carpet fibers. After agitating the carpet, the machine extracts the water and cleaning solution along with the loosened dirt, leaving the carpet clean and only slightly damp.

Carpet cleaners come in various sizes and designs, ranging from small portable models to larger, more powerful machines designed for professional use. Unlike steam cleaners, carpet cleaners do not rely on high-temperature steam for cleaning, which means they may not have the same sanitizing capabilities.

Steam CleanerCarpet Cleaner
Uses high-temperature steamUses water and cleaning solution
Can sanitize surfacesPrimarily focuses on cleaning carpets
Can clean various surfacesNot suitable for hard floors

Both steam cleaners and carpet cleaners offer effective cleaning solutions for maintaining carpets and other surfaces. Considering the differences in their cleaning methods and capabilities, the choice between a steam cleaner and a carpet cleaner will depend on the specific needs and preferences of the user.

Differences Between Steam Cleaners and Carpet Cleaners

While both steam cleaners and carpet cleaners serve the primary purpose of deep cleaning carpets and other floor surfaces, they employ distinct methods and have differing advantages and disadvantages. This section will focus on the differences in cleaning techniques, the use of chemicals and detergents, cost, drying time, and environmental impact.

Cleaning Techniques

Steam cleaners use hot water vapor to break down dirt and grime, making it easier to remove. This process, called steam cleaning or hot water extraction, involves spraying hot water onto the carpet and then extracting it, along with the loosened dirt. On the other hand, carpet cleaners, also known as carpet shampooers, use a combination of water, detergent or cleaning solution, and mechanical agitation to clean carpets.

Chemicals and Detergents

Steam cleaners typically rely on the power of heated water vapor and do not require the use of chemicals or detergents, although some models may include a cleaning solution compartment for added effectiveness. In contrast, carpet cleaners commonly use detergents combined with mechanical brushing to remove dirt and stains from carpets. Some carpet cleaning solutions may contain harsh chemicals, which may not be suitable for all carpet types or individuals with sensitivities.


Both steam cleaners and carpet cleaners come in a range of prices, depending on their features and capabilities. Steam cleaners are generally more expensive upfront, but they may save money in the long term as they do not require the purchase of cleaning solutions or detergents. Carpet cleaners, while often less expensive initially, may necessitate ongoing costs for cleaning solutions.

Drying Time

Due to their cleaning methods, steam cleaners typically leave carpets drier than carpet cleaners. The hot water extraction method used by steam cleaners allows more water to be removed during the cleaning process, resulting in faster drying times. Conversely, carpet cleaners often leave carpets damper because of the higher volume of water and cleaning solution used.

Environmental Impact

Steam cleaners are generally considered more environmentally friendly than carpet cleaners. Since they do not require chemicals or detergents, they produce less waste and have fewer negative impacts on the environment. On the other hand, carpet cleaners typically involve the use of chemicals and detergents that may be harmful to the environment and contribute to waste when disposed of improperly.

Deep Cleaning and Odor Removal

When it comes to deep cleaning and odor removal from carpets and upholstery, the choice between steam cleaners and carpet cleaners is essential. In this section, we will explore the pros and cons of both methods in terms of deep cleaning and odor elimination.

Steam Cleaning

Steam cleaners use high-temperature steam to break down dirt, grime, stains, and bacteria within fibers. This cleaning method effectively lifts and removes unwanted particles, providing a deep clean. Some of the main benefits of steam cleaning include:

  • Chemical-free cleaning process
  • Effectively removes allergens and bacteria
  • Can clean various surfaces like hardwood and tile

However, steam cleaning also has some drawbacks:

  • It may take longer for the carpet to dry, leading to potential mold or dampness issues if not adequately ventilated
  • Not as effective in removing set-in stains or heavy soil build-up

Carpet Cleaning

Carpet cleaners use a combination of water, cleaning solution, and mechanical brushes to break up and lift soil and stains from the carpet fibers. This method is particularly effective for heavy soiling and set-in stains. Some advantages of carpet cleaning are:

  • Deep cleaning with the help of specialized cleaning agents
  • Removal of stubborn stains
  • Carpet fibers can regain their original appearance and texture

However, carpet cleaning has its downsides too:

  • Use of chemicals might retain residues on carpet fibers
  • Not as versatile for cleaning other surfaces

In conclusion, both steam cleaning and carpet cleaning can be effective methods for deep cleaning and odor removal in carpets. The choice between the two depends on the level of soil, specific concerns like allergens, and personal preferences for a more eco-friendly solution.

Cleaning Surfaces and Areas

In this section, we will discuss the cleaning capabilities of steam cleaners and carpet cleaners for various surfaces and areas, including carpets and rugs, furniture and upholstery, and hard floors.

Carpets and Rugs

Steam cleaners, also known as steam mops, are an excellent option for cleaning and sanitizing carpets and rugs. They use hot water vapor to lift dirt, grime, and allergens from carpet fibers. The high heat also kills bacteria, germs, and mites, making your carpets and rugs healthier for your family.

Carpet cleaners, on the other hand, use a combination of water, detergents, and powerful suction to remove dirt and stains from carpets and rugs. They can effectively clean deeply embedded dirt and stubborn stains that might not be easily removed by steam cleaners. However, they require more time to dry as they leave carpets and rugs slightly damp.

Furniture and Upholstery

Steam cleaners have attachments specifically designed for cleaning furniture and upholstery. The high heat is useful in removing dirt, odors, and harmful pathogens from these surfaces, and it typically has a faster drying time compared to carpet cleaners.

Carpet cleaners can be used to clean furniture and upholstery as well, but they require specialized attachments for this purpose. They can remove deep-set stains and dirt, but the drying time is longer, which might not be ideal for some users.

Hard Floors

Steam cleaners are an effective option for cleaning and sanitizing hard floors, such as tile, hardwood, and linoleum. The heat generated by the steam cleaner removes dirt, grime, and bacteria without using harsh chemicals. However, it is important to ensure compatibility with your floor type to prevent any potential damage caused by high heat or moisture.

Carpet cleaners are not designed to clean hard floors and should not be used on them. Their primary function is to clean carpets and rugs, and using them on hard surfaces could cause damage or ineffective cleaning results.

Best Practices for Choosing and Using Cleaners

Selecting a Cleaner for Your Needs

When choosing between a steam cleaner and a carpet cleaner, consider your specific needs. Steam cleaners are versatile tools that can clean various surfaces and materials, making them suitable for multi-purpose cleaning. Carpet cleaners, on the other hand, focus on deep-cleaning carpets and rugs.

To select the best cleaner, evaluate the surfaces you need to clean and the frequency of cleaning. If you have a mix of hard floors and carpets, a steam cleaner may be more suitable. However, if your primary concern is maintaining your carpets, a dedicated carpet cleaner would be a better choice.

Maintaining Your Cleaner

Regardless of which cleaner you choose, proper maintenance is crucial to ensure its longevity and effectiveness. Regularly empty and clean water tanks, and remove debris from brushes and nozzles. Follow the manufacturer’s guidelines for each specific model to keep the cleaner in optimal condition.

Additionally, using the recommended cleaning solutions for your device can help prevent issues caused by incompatible chemicals or residues.

Using the Right Tools and Accessories

Both steam cleaners and carpet cleaners come with various tools and accessories tailored to specific cleaning tasks. Understand which accessories work best for your needs and utilize them accordingly.

  • For steam cleaners, attachments like brushes, nozzles, and squeegees are available to help clean different surfaces or reach tight spaces. Be sure to match the accessory with the appropriate cleaning job.
  • Carpet cleaners, on the other hand, typically come with specialized brushes optimised for deep-cleaning fibers, while additional attachments may be designed for spot cleaning or upholstery care.

By understanding the purpose and use of each tool, you’ll achieve better cleaning results and make the most out of your purchase.

Popular Brands and Models

When considering steam cleaners and carpet cleaners, it’s essential to look at the various popular brands and models available in the market. These devices offer unique features and capabilities that suit different cleaning needs and budgets.

One of the top brands in the cleaning industry is Bissell. They offer a wide range of steam and carpet cleaning models catering to both home and professional use. Some popular Bissell models include:

  • Bissell PowerFresh Steam Mop
  • Bissell SpotClean ProHeat Portable Spot Carpet Cleaner
  • Bissell ProHeat 2X Revolution Max Clean Pet Pro Full-Size Carpet Cleaner

Another well-known brand is Hoover, which also provides a variety of cleaning devices, focusing on efficiency and convenience. A few notable Hoover models are:

  • Hoover Power Scrub Elite Pet Upright Carpet Cleaner
  • Hoover SteamVac with CleanSurge Carpet Cleaner
  • Hoover SmartWash Automatic Carpet Cleaner

You can find popular steam and carpet cleaner brands and models on various platforms, with Amazon being one of the most convenient online retailers. Amazon offers a vast selection of models, competitive prices, and customer reviews to help you make an informed decision.

Before concluding the purchase, it’s helpful to read user reviews and compare the specifications, features, and prices of different models. This process ensures you find the right steam or carpet cleaner tailored to your requirements and preferences.

Professional Services Vs DIY Cleaning

When it comes to steam cleaning and carpet cleaning, homeowners have the option to choose between professional services and do-it-yourself (DIY) methods. There are pros and cons to both approaches, which vary depending on factors such as budget, time, and specific cleaning needs.

Professional carpet cleaners bring expertise and specialized equipment that may not be available to the average homeowner. This makes them more efficient in tackling stubborn stains and deeper cleaning. For instance, when dealing with pet urine, professionals have access to specialized enzymes that break down the particles and eliminate odors. Moreover, they know the right techniques and products to use to prevent weakening or damaging the carpet fibers.

On the other hand, DIY carpet cleaning methods can be more budget-friendly as they often involve renting a steam cleaner or carpet cleaner from a local store. While this option may be sufficient for regular maintenance, it may not be as effective in addressing more severe issues such as pet stains or heavily soiled carpets.

Both professional and DIY cleaning methods may use different approaches, such as:

  • Hot water extraction (steam cleaning)
  • Dry cleaning with absorbent compounds
  • Encapsulation with low-moisture cleaning solutions
  • Bonnet cleaning with a rotating pad

It is crucial to consider the specific needs of the carpets and the level of expertise necessary when choosing between professional services and DIY cleaning. For instance, if the carpet is relatively new and has no severe staining issues, a DIY approach could be sufficient. However, for carpets with accumulated dirt or those under warranty that require periodic professional cleaning, hiring a professional service may be more suitable.

Health Benefits of Clean Carpets and Floors

Keeping carpets and floors clean plays a significant role in maintaining a healthy indoor environment. Clean carpets and floors can not only improve the appearance of a home but also contribute to the overall well-being of its inhabitants by reducing allergens, bacteria, and dust mites.

One major benefit of clean carpets and floors is the reduction of allergens. Allergens such as pollen, pet dander, and dust can accumulate in carpets and on floors. Regular cleaning with a steam cleaner or carpet cleaner helps remove these allergens, leading to a healthier home environment and less irritation for those with allergies.

Another benefit is the elimination of bacteria. Moisture and spills can lead to the growth of bacteria on carpets and floors, which can cause unpleasant odors and pose health risks. Steam cleaners and carpet cleaners are equipped to sanitize surfaces, effectively killing bacteria and maintaining a hygienic living space.

Dust mites are another common issue in carpets and floors. They are microscopic creatures that feed on dust particles and can cause allergic reactions in some people. Regular carpet and floor cleaning can help reduce the presence of dust mites, thereby preventing potential health issues for people with dust mite sensitivities.

Frequent cleaning of carpets and floors not only benefits the health of inhabitants directly but also contributes to improved air quality. Clean surfaces lead to less dust and fewer pollutants in the air, which can be a significant advantage for people with respiratory issues or compromised immune systems.

Leave a Comment